Reddit’s menstrual care communities are a goldmine of feedback, revealing recurring complaints about period underwear care. These aren’t minor inconveniences but dealbreakers that drive negative reviews and product abandonment. Here, we break down the three most persistent issues reported by users.
One of the most common Reddit complaints? Blood stains that remain even after washing—often because users made a critical mistake: rinsing with hot water instead of cold. As one Reddit user aptly explains, “Blood contains proteins that coagulate with heat. Hot water sets stains and damages the absorbent fibres.” This simple error turns a temporary mark into a permanent blemish, leaving users frustrated and less likely to repurchase.
Stains also set when period underwear is left unrinsed for hours (or days) before washing—this issue plagues all styles, from everyday reusable leak proof underwear to heavy-duty overnight period underwear. Reddit threads are filled with stories of users who tossed soiled underwear in a hamper, only to find stains that won’t lift later. For retailers, this means educating your customers on timely rinsing is key to reducing complaints about stains and protecting your brand’s perceived quality.
Foul odors—described by Reddit users as everything from blood and pennies to an “ocean smell”—are another top grievance. Perhaps the most jarring complaint comes from a user who shared: “I rinse them after use, but after washing them in the machine… the smell is extremely intolerable and oddly worse after machine washing—worse even than when they’re actually soiled with blood.”
The root cause? Protein residue and buildup that isn’t fully removed during washing. When blood proteins linger in the absorbent layers, they break down over time, creating persistent odors. Harsh detergents, fabric softeners, or incomplete rinsing can exacerbate the problem—even for period underwear without pfas, which uses gentle, eco-friendly fabrics that require careful cleaning to avoid odor buildup. This leaves users feeling like their period underwear is unsanitary—even after cleaning.
Cold water prevents blood proteins from coagulating and protects the absorbent layer. If it cannot be washed immediately, it is recommended to temporarily store the dirty underwear in a waterproof bag to prevent the growth of bacteria and the formation of stains.
For stubborn stains that do appear, skip hot water and harsh bleach (which damages absorbent fibers). Instead, recommend user-tested solutions from Reddit: mix baking soda with cold water to create a paste, gently scrub the stain, and let it sit for 15–20 minutes before washing. Oxygen-based stain removers also work well—just avoid chlorine bleach, which breaks down the fabric’s absorbent core.
Remember: Heat destroys the moisture-absorbing ability of menstrual underwear! The night version is particularly sensitive to this due to its thicker moisture absorbing layer. Never put underwear in the dryer or expose it to the sun. High temperatures will destroy its elasticity and waterproof membrane, causing leakage and greatly shortening its lifespan. The correct approach is to place it in a cool and ventilated place to dry. Only air drying can preserve the absorbent layer and ensure that the product continues to be effective within 2-3 years of use.
The smell of menstrual blood is that of protein decay, which cannot be washed away with ordinary laundry detergent. It becomes moldy and smelly when hidden in multiple layers of absorbent cotton.
1. The fastest first aid: soak in cold water with white vinegar (no bacteriostasis or hardening)
Cold water + half a bottle of white vinegar
Soak for 15 minutes, do not soak for too long
Rub gently and rinse with water.
White vinegar decomposes the fishy odor of menstrual blood proteins and specifically cures residual odor
2. Stubborn old odor: baking soda + salt
Cold water + a spoonful of baking soda + a spoonful of salt
Soak for 20 minutes before washing to deeply absorb the odor from the cotton layer
3. Never use it
84 Disinfectant: Destroys the waterproof and leak-proof layer, making it more smelly the more you wash it, and it also fades and hardens.
Hot water: menstrual blood solidifies in the interlayer and will smell for the rest of your life.
Prolonged soaking for more than 30 minutes
As a retailer or brand, addressing these cleaning challenges isn’t just about helping end-users—it’s about protecting your bottom line. When customers struggle with period underwear stains, odors, or reduced absorbency, they’re more likely to return products, leave negative reviews, and stop buying from you. By providing clear, actionable period underwear care guidance, you’ll:
As a professional period underwear manufacturer, S·KAIFEI Underwear Factory is committed to innovating fabric technology while collaborating with retail partners to promote proper period underwear care, maximizing the resolution of end-user troubles. We have always been dedicated to supporting all our partners with the following advantages: optional colors, customizable fabrics, flexible size options, and products that fully comply with FDA, OEKO-TEX, GOTS, OCS, and GRS certifications. If you are looking for a reliable partner to jointly develop the period underwear market, please contact us.
Table of Contents